Whitby Pier Ladder Concerns: Ladders in the News

A recent news report from the BBC discusses how concerns have been raised over the replacement of wooden ladders with a steel alternative on the Grade II listed East Pier in Whitby.

Three of the 29ft 6in (9m) long ladders are located on the western side of the pier and the other two are located on the eastern side of the pier, both providing pedestrian access.

Locals have raised concerns about the visual impact of the galvanised steel ladders on the historic site, claiming that they negatively impact the character and appearance of the area.  

However as stated in a report prepared for the Scarborough and Whitby planning committee, the previous timber ladders were hardly original and have likely “been replaced numerous times over the centuries as the result of the maritime environment”.

The report added that the steel ladders have been fixed and installed in the exact same location with the same measurements as the previous timber ladders. Plus, the colour and appearance of the new ladders would likely dull down relatively quickly and begin to “blend more comfortably with the stonework” and thus “no harm would result to the overall heritage significance of the East Pier”.

Are steel ladders better than wooden ladders? 

So aesthetics aside, which type of ladder is actually better suited to this sort of situation: wood or steel?

Steel Ladders

Pros 

• Steel ladders are extremely robust and able to handle heavy loads without bending or buckling.
• Steel ladders can withstand rough handling and environmental factors, making them ideal for outdoor use.
• Steel ladders can be easily repaired by welding. 

Cons

• Steel ladders are heavy and hard to transport and manoeuvre.
• Steel ladders are prone to rust and corrosion if not coated properly. 
• Steel is a conductor of electricity and heat, so steel ladders can be dangerous to use around electrical hazards or in environments where the ladder could become very hot. 

Wooden Ladders

Pros 

• Wooden ladders can be robust and withstand daily use for many years.
• Wooden ladders are often designed for comfort and ease of climbing.
• Wooden ladders do not conduct electricity. 

Cons

• Wood is susceptible to rot, decay and damage from moisture.
• Wood can warp, split and crack due to temperature fluctuations. 
• Wooden ladders need to be inspected regularly for signs of damage. 

Whether you're after a wooden ladder or a metal ladder, we've got both here at Ladders UK Direct!

Shop Wooden Ladders Shop Steel Ladders